BECOME A MEMBER TODAY

The campfire never goes out, and neither does the weird. Become a member of the Tall Tale Social Cult and you're not just listening anymore, you're in.

Members get two shows nobody else hears:

TFD: After Dark — the main show, raw and uncut. Same episodes, none of the edits, every cursed tangent left in. (And yeah, "TFD" stays as a nod to where we started.)

The Butterscotch Gang Hang — a loose, members-only hang for the Butterscotch Gang (that's you, you beautiful weirdos), a fresh handful of scary stories that didn't make the cut, every month.

Plus first dibs on every new episode, extended cuts, and more weird already in the pipeline.

Pull up a log, we’ll see you fireside.

(Heads up: YouTube memberships are paused while we grow the new channel. The YouTube button below is for subscribing; do it anyway, it's free and it helps.)

JOIN THE CULT

SELECT YOUR PLATFORM OF CHOICE TO JOIN:

become a member on Spotify
become a member on spotify
Purple podcast app icon with a white microphone symbol in the center.
Become a member on Apple Podcasts
YouTube logo with a red play button and the text 'YouTube' below it.
YouTube logo with a black rounded square background and a white play button in the center.

OR SUPPORT THE SHOW WITH A ONE TIME DONATION

$
3% Cover the Fee

  • "I’ve been searching for a new podcast for a while, glad to have been recommended this one. Very informative/entertaining. Got me and some friends to talk about some personal “freaky experiences.” Can’t wait to hear more episodes!! Plus they’re from Alaska, love to support local projects.”

    -MarinaHA23

  • "My go to podcast for all things spooky. I’ve listened to a lot of podcasts ranging from very highly known podcasts to the lesser known podcasts and this is by far my favorite. Really down to earth people that are spontaneously humorous and knowledgeable that keep me very entertained through out my work days! Honestly these guys can out perform the big guys when it comes to podcasts and they deserve more attention so let’s get these guys to the top where they belong! Seriously guys keep up the good work! You guys rock!"

    -Tactical Slippers

  • "Woof, the whole podcast I oscillated between paranoid fury and calmed reassurance! “How could they do this to us?!” “Oh…OK, that makes sense, that’s reasonable.” Great job gang, on the banter, the topic, the research, the insight, and the show overall! Could not give it a higher recommendation! And these are the early shows! Can’t wait to see what happens when they find their rhythm and these seeds they’ve planted are ready to harvest!”

    -Dorsey Ambrose Buchanan

  • "You guys keep things interesting regardless of topic, great stuff and I appreciate the humor along with the paranormal!"

    -Michigan Mamadukes

  • "I usually am annoyed by other pods’ mindless chitchat before getting to the good stuff. These guys are actually funny without passive-aggressively flaunting that they think they are funny, because they actually are quite entertaining. Their stories are good and schpoopy too."

    -SaltCityGal

  • "This podcast is so entertaining! Love the banter and the jokes in between the spookiness!"

    "This podcast is so entertaining! Love the banter and the jokes in between the spookiness!" -Meowmaste

  • "The Best Around……..Nothing is ever going to bring them down! Two of the best podcast hosts since Tony Merkel hit the scene. Great topics, awesome conversation and a resident skeptic “ Chrissy” who admits when he is wrong or when a demon is touching his butt and that is Freaky Deaky……."

    -Shadow-976

  • "I love this podcast!! I love their interactions and banter ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️"

    -DeedleChulaShella

  • "One of my favorites! These guys are so funny together. It’s unusual for a father and son-in-law to get along so well (just my opinion). But the banter between these two are so funny that I find myself laughing out loud almost every episode. Love them. Love this podcast!"

    -Driver1960

  • "Paranormal with a splash of humor. I’m hooked!"

    -Tabbiecatzzz

  • "Hilarious and informative! I love this podcast! Christian and Scott are my favorite hosts and I listen to a lot of podcasts. You two are the best. Much love and success❤️"

    -Liza Jane24

  • "HIDDEN GEM! I finally found a good paranormal podcast other than Jim Harold! Love listening to these guys even though Christian is wrong but it’s okay. Thank you for the freaky deaky-ness!"

    -hfhehfxdhwjfhdhufhfhrh

  • "Quickly became a fav. I have a handful of paranormal/cryptid podcasts I listen to weekly and these guys are great. I feel like I’m sitting in the room during the discussions. They are hilarious. It’s probably the only podcast I actually laugh at just because of the nature of the banter between the hosts. Please keep on keepin’ on!"

    -907MklaS

  • "It's a good show! I found out about this show by picking up a free sticker at the matsu college. I’m not a big conspiracy theory person, but listening to this podcast makes my day😂. This show has so many golden moments it makes me laugh. Definitely recommend."

    -TaliahO